And The Valley Shook: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Backing the Pack for NC State Fans!


BlogPoll Returns

RankTeamDelta
1 Texas Tech 25
2 Alabama 24
3 Florida 23
4 Texas 22
5 Oklahoma 21
6 Southern Cal 20
7 Utah 19
8 Penn State 18
9 Boise State 17
10 Ohio State 16
11 TCU 15
12 Michigan State 14
13 Oklahoma State 13
14 Georgia 12
15 Missouri 11
16 Cincinnati 10
17 Maryland 9
18 North Carolina 8
19 Boston College 7
20 Georgia Tech 6
21 Florida State 5
22 Miami (Florida) 4
23 Ball State 3
24 Pittsburgh 2
25 LSU 1

 

Dropped Out:

Star-divide

I was admittedly depressed last week and didn't submit a blogpoll.  That was my bad, people. I just couldn't bring myself to talk about football after the Bama game.  I did, however, get this poll in on time, I'm just posting it late because I was more interested in talking about our fan meltdown.  So let's break this thing down.

The top two.  I'm choosing Texas Tech over Bama because I am more impressed by their wins.  I had been selling Tech short all season and was very reluctant to put them in the top ten due to their truly awful OOC schedule.  But now that they have beaten Texas and blown out Okie State, i'm a believer.  Even if they lose to OU, Tech is legit. 

The lurking powers.  Florida is playing better than anyone in the country, but they did lose to Ole Miss.  UT gets ahead of OU by virtue of the head to head win and the fact UT played a brutal four-week stretch and went 3-1.  USC looks good not great, but they get the 6 slot.

The mid-majors and Big Ten.  I think there are some legit teams here.  Utah has proven themselves, and I'm still a huge believer in TCU.  Boise St has earned the benefit of the doubt.  There's the trio of Big Ten teams which are yet to completely sort out: PSU, OSU, and MSU. 

The flawed.  Oklahoma St is a good team who has proven that they aren't as good as the monster teams in the Big 12 South.  Mizzou and Georgia have beaten the teams beneath them and lost to the teams haead of them.  And I love Cincinnati and the way they are fighting through injuries.

The ACC.  Throw a dart to rank the top six ACC teams.  I honestly have no clue.  It's guesswork.

Lucky to be ranked.  Ball St is undefeated but has played a joke of a schedule.  Pitt has finally lived down an embarrassing opening loss.  And LSU could very easily not be ranked.  I thought long and hard about BYU or Oregon St.  The difference is that I still think LSU hasn't lost to a poor team and they d have some good wins.  I'm anti-BYU, as no good team should need a miracle to beat Washington.  And OSU?  i'm running out of excuses not to rank them.  I probably should have.  I'm a shameless homer, I guess. 

0 recs | Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

How can you rank LSU and not Oregon St?

LSU has beaten nobody in anybody’s current top 25 and Oregon St beat USC.

LSU has lost 3 games to top 14 teams (according to your rankings).
Oregon St has lost 2 games to top 7 teams (according to your rankings) and to an unranked (but not bad) Stanford team on the road in the first game of the year by a touchdown.

So if you cancel Oregon St’s best win with their worst loss, they look a lot like LSU. Do I think they would beat LSU? No, but there resume is at least as impressive in my opinion.

Which brings me to my next question…Are you basing this on resume or who beats who on a neutral field?

by LSU Jonno on Nov 19, 2008 4:23 PM CST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Good point

No, I admit I’m a shameless homer on that one. I really shouldn’t rank LSU ahead of OSU. Primarily, I believe in resume ranking with a component for “who wins on a neutral field”. Probably 70% resume, 25% who’s better, 5% gut feeling.

And it’s not just wins and losses, the fact OSU got absolutely crushed by Penn St matters. Then again, we got crushed by Florida.

by Poseur on Nov 19, 2008 6:35 PM CST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about LSU Tigers.
Start posting about the Tigers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Rasco
Small
Rasco
3831_8_small
Jared Mitchell has to be on top of the World
Small
Storm Johnson
Gse_multipart30441_small
ATVS on Facebook

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

ATVS Twitter Link

follow Les on Twitter


Managers

Gse_multipart30441_small Richard Pittman

Editors

Me_and_beer_small Poseur

Les-miles-bears-2_small GeauxBears

Authors

Dduzcaz8lg8xca1e9umxcayb6h89casec7jycanko951caqq3246cavdxhrccam82axacat2kr9qca2oz3rsca64takzcaw0toprca4hx60mcahrmqq0cad7ixvgcayr1dn9cahuxjuicaeieutgca3t3udbcaeieq7pca2s0zi6_small Tortfeasor

Official Partner of CBS Sports