And The Valley Shook: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Can Tebow Say No To Anything?

CFN Georgia Preview

This is Georgia's year. This is the time when everything has to come together for a national championship. An SEC title would be nice, another BCS appearance would be solid, but unless Richt is holding that crystal football in Miami at around 11:30 p.m. on January 8, 2009, this season will be a failure. While that might seem harsh, with the level of excellence set by the rest of the SEC when it comes to winning national titles, it's an all or nothing year for a Dawg team that's really that good.

See, this is the attitude I don't much care for from national media, even national media I otherwise like, such as Pete Fiutak at CFN.

How can a season be a failure if it falls short of a mythical national championship?  First, Georgia has, as has been heavily documented, a hell of a schedule.  Road trips to Arizona State, LSU, and Auburn plus a neutral site game against Florida is a gauntlet that the Detroit Lions (random mediocre NFL team that is nonetheless much better than any college football team) would be mildly pleased to escape unblemished.  And then they have to beat Tennessee at home, South Carolina on the road, and if they make it that far, another quality opponent (possibly in a rematch) in the SEC Championship Game.  That's tough.  And that's just to get to the winner take all game at the end, against ANOTHER good team (or possibly Ohio State).*

Second, so much of the equation that puts a team into the BCSNCG is uncontrollable.  I think many people believe, rightly IMO, that the winner of the Ohio State-USC matchup has at least a 50-50 shot of making it to the national championship game, and heck the loser might make it.  They BOTH might make it, regardless of who wins.  If Georgia survives its schedule but has a loss, and there are two undefeated BCS-conference teams out there, Georgia (or whoever else wins the SEC) is out of luck.

This is why, and stop me if I've said this before, even really good teams should have as their goal to win the conference.  Let everything else fall where it may.  If you win your conference, no one should complain that you didn't do more, because doing more requires a measure of luck.  Even an undefeated team can miss the BCSNCG if they don't get the right luck (though Georgia appears to be a situation where they would be assured of making it if they win out, possibly squeezing out some other deserving undefeated team).

So, Georgia fans, if you listen to me at all (and I'm not going to delude myself into thinking you do), don't buy into this media hype.  Don't fall into the trap of thinking that anything short of a national championship is a failure.  If you get your hotly anticipated conference championship, consider the rest lagniappe. After all, the national championship is just for fun anyway.

*I kid. I kid.

0 recs  |  Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Ok

But you do agree that Georgia fans should impale themselves should the team fail to win the SEC right? RIGHT? Just making sure. Because that would be cool.

Agreed though, the convoluted BCS generally makes it a crapshoot on winning the MNC; Auburn 2004 will be the everlasting example of that.

by GeauxTigers on Aug 4, 2008 1:13 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

At least they're in control

The one thing Georgia has going for it is that it controls its own destiny. There is absolutely no way, should the Bulldogs go undefeated, that they would fail to make the NCG. I don’t care if there are six undefeated teams.

However, if they stumble, and recent history shows SEC teams will stumble, it is all about luck and opportunity. LSU learned that last year. But it certainly helps when that opportunity comes up to be able to point back to a brutal schedule and signature wins to earn that coveted spot in the promise land (the BCSNCG).

by Purple Reign on Aug 4, 2008 2:24 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I do see his point. And I do believe CFN is one of those sites that as the season progresses, will revise their views. They aren’t afraid of changing their mind when the data changes, which I genuinely respect.

But this is Georgia’s year. If they fail to make the BCS title game, they will, however unfairly, be tagged as a program that can’t win the big one. This season is a program defining season. It’s not wrong of CFN to point that out. If Georgia doesn’t go to the title game, they will be perceived as the Buffalo Bills of college football (speaking of unfair reputations).

It’s a shame no one respects consistent excellence. Georgia is in the top ten every year and they have been one of the winningest programs of the past decade. But they’ve never even sniffed a national title. I’ll respect their program regardless. But I don’t think Joe Fan will. Unfair? Yes. But this is a tough business.

by Poseur on Aug 4, 2008 3:37 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

But this is Georgia’s year. If they fail to make the BCS title game, they will, however unfairly, be tagged as a program that can’t win the big one. This season is a program defining season. It’s not wrong of CFN to point that out. If Georgia doesn’t go to the title game, they will be perceived as the Buffalo Bills of college football (speaking of unfair reputations).

But we should reject it. It’s a bad attitude that is pervasive throughout college football every year. Last year, us, USC, and Ohio State all faced it at one time or another, the attitude that anything less than a national title is failure. Ohio State certainly has it again this year, as does Georgia, which means one of them will fail, and probably both of them will fail. If the college football world is ever going to get smarter, it will only be when people start openly rejecting these notions.

Richard Pittman

by Richard Pittman on Aug 4, 2008 9:31 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about LSU Tigers.
Start posting about the Tigers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Fiddler_on_the_roof_fiddler_1__small
From RockyTopTalk.com-Tennessee reportedly loses J.C. Copeland to LSU
Small
If you could bring back one Tiger from the 2000's for next year's team, who would it be?
Alabama_logo2_small
Really ESPN?
Got_les_small
NSD Notice to LSU Recruits: This Is the Real Les Miles!
Small
GIANT slap in the face ESPN
Got_les_small
Does Negative Fan Speak Really Impact Recruiting?
Got_les_small
Dooley to UT, Crowton to La Tech??
Lsu_small
I Am Absolutley Dumbfounded By This
Small
ANOTHER TIGERT CHOKE STARTS A YEAR
Small
2007 outback bowl anyone?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

ATVS Twitter Link

follow Les on Twitter


Managers

Pb140006_small PodKATT

Editors

Gse_multipart30441_small Richard Pittman

Me_and_beer_small Poseur

Lsu_logo_small Purple Reign

Photo_small Dane Noble

Authors

Dduzcaz8lg8xca1e9umxcayb6h89casec7jycanko951caqq3246cavdxhrccam82axacat2kr9qca2oz3rsca64takzcaw0toprca4hx60mcahrmqq0cad7ixvgcayr1dn9cahuxjuicaeieutgca3t3udbcaeieq7pca2s0zi6_small Tortfeasor

Koolaid_small Jrlz

Official Partner of CBS Sports