ATVSQBPI: Week 5
Week 5 saw the numbers for quarterbacks decline just a little, but we're still seeing an upward trend relative to last season. As a reminder, ATVSQBPI is calculated by the following formula (yards passing + yards rushing + 20*touchdowns passing + 20*touchdowns rushing - 30*interceptions)/(passing attempts + rushing attempts). It is an improved version of the traditional passer rating and gives a result in an easy-to-read yards/touch format. Without further ado, here are the number for the ATVS Quarterback Productivity Index for Week 5.
Quarterback
ATVSQBPI yards/attempt
Ryan Mallett
10.7
Tyson Lee
8.1
Stephen Garcia
7.9
Joe Cox
7.1
Greg McElroy
6.7
Jonathan Crompton
6.5
Chris Todd
6.4
Jevan Snead
6.0
Jordan Jefferson
4.8
Mike Hartline
2.3
Larry Smith
2.1
Analysis and discussion after the jump.
Obviously, Ryan Mallett made a big comeback from last week, when the Crimson Tide put a hurt on him. He had a great game this week, to lead all SEC quarterbacks with a 10.0 yards per attempt average with 4 touchdown passes.
And yes, that's Tyson Lee with solid numbers there, against legitimate competition no less. Too bad his team lost despite his good numbers.
And even more surprising, Jonathan Crompton not only had decent passing numbers, but actually beat Chris Todd, who had been consistently among the top performers in this metric.
Jevan Snead continues to fail to jump up into the upper echelon of the conference, and Jordan Jefferson had a tough night despite making some good throws. His 16 rushing attempts, many of them for losses, just killed his ATVSQBPI, along with his interception without a touchdown pass.
It is becoming a theme that Alabama opponents have a very poor ATVSQBPI, and Mike Hartline continues the trend.
Yeah, it was kind of an up-is-down week around the SEC for quarterbacks. Tyson Lee was among the best. Jonathan Crompton was competent, thanks to his receivers making some plays. Jevan Snead was below average. And the team that had the biggest win of the week (LSU) had among the lowest ATVSQBPIs.
5 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I am not sure of the worth of a formula...
that supports Tyson Lee and Joe Cox’s performances Saturday over some of those other qbs’ performances. I have been thinking the same thing when looking at the numbers each week. What is your impression? Do you think Joe Cox had a better game than McElroy, Crompton or Todd?
The beauty of it is that it cuts through all the preconceived notions..
If a quarterback has a good day, he has a good ATVSQBPI. If he has a bad day, he has a bad ATVSQBPI. It is, like every other statistic imaginable in football, dependent on the level of competition and on the help you get from other players, but it is merciless in its refusal to give the media-driven stories any credence if they do not deserve any.
Tyson Lee and Joe Cox each ended up with pretty nice days. I did not see Tyson Lee play, but Cox ended up with fine numbers despite a very slow start, and he avoided turnovers. That’s not bad.
Father. Husband. Lawyer. Nerd.
by Richard Pittman on Oct 6, 2009 6:08 PM CDT up reply actions
Uhh...
we’ll have to agree to disagree on Cox’s play. I thought he was in way over his head. He only threw one really nice pass all day (the td to Green), missed some wide open wrs (16 incompletions) and made the BIGGEST turnover of the day when he got picked by Riley (leaving 21 seconds on the clock). All this while getting very little pressure in the form of blitzes from LSU. I am not arguing Jefferson played better (considering 0 td passes and the 6 sacks) but Todd (19/32 for 218 yds and 1 td) and McElroy (15/26 for 148 yrds and 2 tds) certainly seem to have more efficient statistics and, more importantly, put their teams in position to win. Crompton aside (20/43 for 259 yrds and 2), I guess I am wondering what about Cox’s stats put him ahead of those guys.
I disagree about the last second pickpick
It was 3rd and 15 and there were 20 seconds left on the clock. At that point a quarterback needs to take chances, and throwing an interception isn’t much worse than throwing an incompletion. Even if he completes that pass, odds are that the dawgs lose.
Now his missing the long ball to Green is a real black mark. If he hits that pass for a 70 yard touchdown I think Georgia wins.
by 4.0 Point Stance on Oct 7, 2009 4:42 PM CDT up reply actions
season stats
Any way you can include cumulative season stats whenever you post this?

by 





















