Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: NCAA Tournament Bubble Watch

WAC Commish Gives Boyd Half-Game Suspension for Toliver Hit.

One of the big moments from last weeks largely forgettable game against La Tech was an early 3rd Qtr pass play to Terrance Toliver that left him on the turf for quite sometime. I was at the game, and did not get the benefit of a replay. From my vantage point of the southwest corner I assumed Chad Boyd, the La Tech player, got a clean, if strong hit that rang Toliver's bell. LSU thought differently and brought it up with the SEC office on Monday (It was an SEC crew for the game). Now, WAC Commish Karl Benson has suspended Boyd a half game for what is now deemed a flagrant foul and Rodgers Redding, the SEC ref supervisor and a member of the NCAA rules commitee, is contemplating disciplinary action for the line judge who had a clear view of the hit and did not make the call. The La Tech fanbase is in meltdown over this and Dooley is "disappointed in the decision and have voiced my respectful disagreement on the rule interpretation and penalty enforcement to the commissioner," which is probaly coach-speak for a conversation that was anything but respectful if Derek has any of Vince in him.

Take a look for yourself at the play. The helmet-to-helmet contact is clear and should have been called, but calling it "flagrant" is all about judging intent. Some have commented that Boyd draws his hands to his body before contact, thus signifying intent, but i dont see it.

Louisiana Tech DB receiver half-game suspension - ESPN

Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I agree

It should absolutely have been flagged for helmet-to-helmet contact, but it’s too much of a bang-bang play to infer intent after the fact. The SEC linesman missed the call. In this particular case that should have been the end of it.

CHAD JONES! WOOOO!!!!

by The Bengal on Nov 20, 2009 5:47 PM CST reply actions  

I agree

There should not have been a suspension of the player but the official should be.

These guys are atrocious – no way he can claim he didn’t see it or had a bad angle or whatever. He was three yards away looking right at it with no one anywhere near his line of sight.

That was a torpedo to the head and could have snapped TTs neck – Clearly it should have been called.

GEAUX TIGERS!!!

by SouthernMan on Nov 20, 2009 10:29 PM CST reply actions  

Why is it not surprising...

…that an SEC official is in someway involved with a fricked-up call?

I agree with the point of intent. It was a penalty, but I don’t see an effort to really put someone out.

by Purpletiger006 on Nov 21, 2009 5:49 AM CST reply actions  

I think the hit should have been flagged but agree that suspension is a bit much.

I do find it interesting that the WAC punishment for this close call play was as much punishment as Urban was willing to dish out for Spikes eye gouging play (which apparently even Spikes felt was too light).

And as long as we are griping about helmet spearing plays, why didn’t the SEC say anything about the blatant spearing play on JJ in the Bama game?

by Displaced Tiger on Nov 21, 2009 8:40 AM CST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about LSU Tigers. Best viewed in Wide mode

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
AL fan Downing's lawyers: "ain't no crime, he was just joshin'"
Small
DeAngelo Peterson and the National Championship
Small
Miles and QBs
Small
Don: Boone is Staying
Small
1958 vs 2011
76224_20070106130217_small
I knew Les was stubborn, but wow...
Small
2012 cornerbacks
Small
Charting the offensive offense: 2012 LSU in the BCS CG
Small
Why I hate Nick Saban and like Erik Gee and Matt Hinton
Img_0145_small
A Bama fan's perspective on tomorrow night's game

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

12 - 9

Conference

2 - 5

Lost 3


Managing Editor / Chief Lackey

Pb140006_small PodKATT

Editors

Gse_multipart30441_small Richard Pittman

Me_and_beer_small Poseur

Tower_small Billy Gomila

Paulcrewe_small Paul Crewe

Authors

Mike_snow_small actioncuse