And The Valley Shook: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Ole Miss-Alabama: "Let's Go Eat.Wait. What Happened?"

Questions Coming Out of Spring Practice

With Spring Practice Officially dead and buried, it is time to look at some of the questions we still have.

1.  How will the revamped offensive line perform?  Last year, the offensive line was one of the strengths of the team, as we ran well and generally protected the QB as much as it could be expected against SEC defenses.  This year, we have to replace 2 of the veteran linemen in Brett Helms and Herman Johnson, both of whom will be in an NFL training camp.  Coming out of Spring, it looks like their spots will be taken by sophomores Josh Dworaczyk and T-Bob Hebert.  What we do not know and can hardly even speculate about at this point is whether those two are really good, or if they're just "better than the alternative".  Offensive line play is always the most important determining factor about how an offense will perform, as poor line play will adversely affect both the running and the passing games, and good line play will open up holes for your running backs and make your QB very comfortable in the pocket.  The play of Dworaczyk and Hebert will go a long way to determining how this team will perform offensively this year.  We know Ciron Black is as solid as a left tackle gets, and Lyle Hitt is a 3-year starter, so we know what he brings.  We will also need Joseph Barksdale to step up his play and go from being "promising" to being "studly".  Word is he is on his way to doing just that, but we will have to see.

2.  Will we get consistently good quarterback play?  LSU fans rightly have high hopes for Jordan Jefferson and Russell Shepard, and we actually have something of a luxury in having Jarrett Lee as an experienced player beginning the season in a backup role.  The problem remains however that we have a VERY young quarterback group.  We don't have any quarterback who's been around long enough to be a junior, and Jarrett Lee's 9 starts makes him by far the most experienced on the roster.  Jordan Jefferson has showed great promise, but we need to remember that he is just a true sophomore, and he has started only 2 games.  We enter the 2009 season with the least experience at the QB spot of any team in the conference, though South Carolina has a somewhat comparable situation.

3.  Will we have productive complementary players at the skill positions?  Brandon Lafell is an outstanding player and a true #1 receiver.  Will we have a quality #2, #3, and #4, or will we have to rely on TE Richard Dickson even more?  After a couple years of looking really great in his uniform, it is Terrance Toliver's turn to become a reliable producer.  Whenever a player transitions from sophomore to junior year, you have to stop talking about his potential and start talking about his production.  At 6'5" and with outstanding speed and athleticism, Toliver's potential is through the roof, but it's time to do something with it.  He ended last year on a high note, catching 16 passes in his final 5 games, after catching only 6 in the previous 8.  If he continues that pace and breaks a few nice gains out of it.  We will also need Chris Mitchell, RJ Jackson, Tim Molton, or one of the other receivers to step up play as well.  Rueben Randle or even Russell Shepard could figure into this in the Fall.  

At running back, we know Charles Scott is a good power running back with the intelligence and durability to be a #1 tailback.  But you need more than that.  Keiland Williams was inconsistent despite solid line play, though he got more productive as the season wore on.  I will speculate that I think he was not in optimum condition at the beginning of the year and he lost a step of speed.  He needs to be a speed back, so he needs to get that step back.  Junior Richard Murphy had a disastrous sophomore season after having high expectations heading into the season.  One of these two guys will have to step up play for LSU to reach its potential.  We do not know if Stevan Ridley will be sufficiently recovered from his injury to be a factor in the 2009 season.  If Keiland or Murphy or Ridley can't be productive behind Scott, we may see a lot of Michael Ford when he reports for his freshman season.

4.  Who will be our backup defensive linemen?

Unlike an offensive line, a defensive line cannot live by its starters alone.  It needs depth.  It needs a rotation.  We believe we have our top 4 offensive linemen in Pep Levingston, Drake Nevis, Al Woods, and Rahim Alem.  We think they are going to be very good-to-outstanding players.  Levingston would be a big surprise to me.  I did not really expect that of him, and I am pleased to hear the good reports.  The questions are who will be backing those guys up, and how will they perform when they're needed?  Charles Alexander brings experience to the defensive tackle position, as he will be on his 6th year of eligibility and was a full-time starter last year.  Other than Cheese, our backups will be very green.  Redshirt freshmen Lavar Edwards, Chancey Aghayere, and Chase Clement appear to have the inside track.  I loved Aghayere when he was a prospect, but he has had to battle back from high school injuries.

5.  Whither the defensive backfield?

We think we're pretty sure that, barring injury, Chad Jones and Patrick Peterson are going to be the starters at corner and at free safety.  Other than that, it's all a mystery.  Chris Hawkins was the only player to start all 13 games last year in the secondary, but he was on the Purple team for the spring game, which would suggest that he has been passed up on the depth chart.  Jai Eugene took his place.  Last year's starting strong safety has been moved to linebacker.  Ron Brooks has won accolades at the position, but no one has said he's won a job.  Karnell Hatcher was a standout last year as a true freshman, and he will have something to say about who plays that spot.  At corner, we have Hawkins, Eugene, and Brandon Taylor battling for the last starting spot opposite Patrick Peterson.  At strong safety we have Ron Brooks and Karnell Hatcher.  Plus we have Derrick Bryant who played a bit as a freshman and who certainly isn't giving up.  Even if we can make some educated guesses about who will be starting, we have absolutely no idea who will come into the game in nickel or dime situations.  There's been some noise we won't have a true nickel package, but we know we'll have a dime.  And let's not forget that super-prospect Craig Loston will be here soon.

0 recs  |  Comment 5 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Some comments...

1) The fact that Hebert was in a no contact jersey all spring makes it really hard to know what to expect there. My biggest problem on our line is size. Ciron is listed at 325, Dworaczyk at 286, Hebert at 282, Hitt at 289, and Barksdale at 315. So Dworaczyk is giving up around 100lbs to what Herman gave us, and Hebert isn’t making up for any of that loss because he is no bigger than Helms was. The interior of our line looks to be a tad undersized for SEC D-lines, in fact it looks a lot like AU’s offensive line from last year. I wouldn’t be surprised if we go to more of an outside rushing threat.

2)

We enter the 2009 season with the least experience at the QB spot of any team in the conference
Not sure what you’re getting at here. Bama’s starting QB has zero starts, and their backups are horrible. Auburn’s starting QB is probably going to be Neil Caudle who also has zero starts. Auburn’s backup will likely be Kodi Burns (if he doesn’t transfer) which would put him in the same category of Lee as far as experience. Arkansas doesn’t have a whole lot of experience in their QB corps either. Mallet started a few games at Michigan but he is only a RS Soph. Sneed will be great at Ole Miss, but who are their backups? The point is QB is not an excuse this year. You can argue we have the second best QB situation in the West, and that is not a hard side to argue.

3) I think the skill positions will work themselves out. We’ve heard too many good things out of Molton and both Tollivers to be worried, combine that with Sheppard and Randle taking snaps at WR in the summer and fall and I’ve got much bigger things to worry about than WR. RB should hopefully work itself out as well.

4) When you have a 6th year senior who has around 20 starts under his belt as your 3rd DT you don’t have a depth problem. Out of the guys you mentioned plus Akiem Hicks coming in this summer we’ll be fine there. In fact they’ll probably use Hicks in a DE/DT role this year. Next year however, will be interesting on the D-line.

5) With Ron Brooks, Karnell Hatcher, and Craig Loston back there all battling for one spot, do you think one of those guys redshirts?

by LSU Jonno on Apr 23, 2009 8:32 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I think the argument could be made either way..

Bama has no QB with starting experience, and only about 11 pass attempts, but their presumptive starter is also a 4th year junior. Our presumptive starter is a true sophomore. While he’s thrown a lot more passes in competitive games, he’s also younger and has had a lot less practice time.

I think of all these questions, the most likely to work itself out favorably is probably the skill position players. We just need either KW or RM to rebound, which is hardly far-fetched. We do need a couple of receivers to emerge, and I think I’m being pretty clear that Terrance Toliver appears genuinely poised to increase his production. We don’t need a big jump over how he FINISHED the year. We just can’t have him repeat his production of the first half of the year.

It’s very unusual to choose to redshirt a player who played extensively as a true freshman, but it may be wise to do so with karnell Hatcher and/or Craig Loston. I sincerely doubt that either one redshirts, however.

OL is a big question. It could turn out fine, but you could look at it as being very troubling that no one was able to pass up an INJURED player who was not an incumbent. Hitt’s a solid player, but I think we have to acknowledge that he is nothing more than “solid”. He’s not a star at guard, just solid, and we will need some push on the interior of the line. There are a lot of good DTs among our opponents this year.

Charles Alexander will make a very solid backup, but there remains a questions of who ELSE will be available off the bench on the DL. We think we know who those guys will be, but not how effective they’ll be. It’s an area where we like to redshirt, but if Aghayere, Clement, or Edwards don’t produce, we may have to rely on a true freshman.

Richard Pittman

by Richard Pittman on Apr 23, 2009 7:56 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

not to be tryin to correct you on your site but...

i understand that Greg McElroy will be a senior, and that means a lot, but he hasnt started ANY games, tho he does have a little more “time” experience, i would argue that LSU isnt alone in the SEC with an unexperienced guy makin the throws…

I just didnt want yall to have any “real” excuses… lol :)

by tidefanstuckatlsu on Apr 25, 2009 9:59 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

According to the ESPN site, which appears to not be updated from last year,

McElroy was a sophomore last year. That’s what I thought he was. You look through it and you can see players you KNOW are a certain class and they’re listed one year behind. I’m pretty sure McElroy’s a junior.

There are definitely a lot of teams out there with unproven QBs. LSU and Bama are two of them. Really, when it comes down to it, only Florida and Ole Miss really have QBs that are proven to be good. Everyone else is either playing someone who struggled last year or is trying to break in someone new.

Richard Pittman

by Richard Pittman on Apr 25, 2009 2:09 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

this could be wrong but...

i am pretty sure he is a senior… maybe that site assumed that he red shirted??

by tidefanstuckatlsu on Apr 27, 2009 1:59 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about LSU Tigers.
Start posting about the Tigers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Fiddler_on_the_roof_fiddler_1__small
From RockyTopTalk.com-Tennessee reportedly loses J.C. Copeland to LSU
Small
If you could bring back one Tiger from the 2000's for next year's team, who would it be?
Alabama_logo2_small
Really ESPN?
Got_les_small
NSD Notice to LSU Recruits: This Is the Real Les Miles!
Small
GIANT slap in the face ESPN
Got_les_small
Does Negative Fan Speak Really Impact Recruiting?
Got_les_small
Dooley to UT, Crowton to La Tech??
Lsu_small
I Am Absolutley Dumbfounded By This
Small
ANOTHER TIGERT CHOKE STARTS A YEAR
Small
2007 outback bowl anyone?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

ATVS Twitter Link

follow Les on Twitter


Managers

Pb140006_small PodKATT

Editors

Gse_multipart30441_small Richard Pittman

Me_and_beer_small Poseur

Lsu_logo_small Purple Reign

Photo_small Dane Noble

Authors

Dduzcaz8lg8xca1e9umxcayb6h89casec7jycanko951caqq3246cavdxhrccam82axacat2kr9qca2oz3rsca64takzcaw0toprca4hx60mcahrmqq0cad7ixvgcayr1dn9cahuxjuicaeieutgca3t3udbcaeieq7pca2s0zi6_small Tortfeasor

Koolaid_small Jrlz

Official Partner of CBS Sports